TruckNet UK users discuss Top Gear
November 13, 2008The most controversial episode of Top Gear (the one that featured a HGV crash stunt) was discussed in depth on the forums even before it aired. After transmission, the programme’s coverage of HGVs and HGV driving was the main subject of further postings and comments. However, most seem to feel that, on the whole, the programme was allegedly rather sympathetic to all the various “difficulties” of driving an HGV or LGV. Apart from that, the programme also made several points that were specifically aimed at car drivers on the problems of manoeuvring such vehicles.
Nevertheless, the majority of forum members point out that Top Gear is generally an entertainment show – and not a serious motoring news show. Therefore, a lot of the comments in fact dismiss the programme as a bit of a laugh. A few HGV drivers are both dissatisfied and unhappy with the way they were portrayed. Yet, was the episode good for the industry?
Discussing the already popular theme of “HGVs in the media”, News of the World columnist – Carole Malone – has made a couple of comments. In her column, Malone claims that she herself had previously been overtaken by an articulated HGV weighing 10 tonnes and yet doing 90mph. Most of her comments (especially the one about the overtaking HGV) were greeted with a little scepticism on the forums. In spite of the comments about Malone’s journalistic talents, as well as her ability to research, there are also those who wonder which model of HGV it was and who the trailer manufacturer was. Nonetheless, most of the forum members firmly believe that Malone’s comments are rather negative and misleading, particularly for the industry itself.